So, the strikes, huh? Was there an issue that so captured the American media’s attention outside the Hamas attack on Israel (something that found itself inextricably wound up in everything from the strikes to the glittering award ceremonies)?
If you don’t know, the TL;DR version is that the writers’ and actors’ guilds in the US went on strike in protest of the studios’ front organisation (the AMPTP) over several issues.
Streaming residuals were one. Conditions around how many writers could work on a TV project and the pay they’d get for it was another, all a result of most streaming series being far shorter than those of the old days of linear TV and making writers’ livings more precarious.
But one of the highest profile snags was the use of AI. Now we live in a world of ChatGPT and Sora, writers and actors are worried they’ll be replaced with computers, and studios are salivating at the thought.
They’re pretending they aren’t, but we all know they were. They’re making all the right noises, Ted Sarandos (for instance) going on the publicity trail to assure everyone AI can’t replace filmmakers.
But they have a considerable PR war to win to usher in the AI age in Hollywood when even audiences seem to be behind writers and actors. The first film where they admitted to using AI, a horror flick called Late Night With the Devil that never would have got this much publicity otherwise, faced an immediate social media backlash.
The co-directors went into damage control, issuing a statement assuring everyone AI was only used for a couple of stills.
Now, the technology is a particularly attractive proposition to the industry after such a rotten 2023. Aside from a few standouts like Barbie and Oppenheimer, last year was littered with expensive and high profile bombs from Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny to Mission: Impossible – Dead Reckoning Part One (and what an unwieldy title that was… much like the movie, really) and plenty more in between.
As a filmmaking collective called credo23.com said in one of the articles I read about the use of AI in films and TV; ‘…it’s not just the actors. It’s the crew, it’s the drivers, it’s everybody. If you don’t have to shoot an actor, you don’t need a set. You don’t need a crew. You don’t need drivers.
‘…this is fueled by abject greed, and … studio and streaming CEOs are looking at an opportunity to reduce the overhead of our human labor to such an extent that they’re paying a fraction of the cost to make these films and could possibly make the same amount in box office. To imagine that they’re not going to go for that is very naive.’
Strong words, and they reflected the belief of many of the striking actors and writers no matter how much boilerplate each side issued about ‘working together’.
Because here’s what’s at stake. It’s a common trope that a movie used to simply compete with other movies coming out the same weekend, but now it’s competing with every movie every made because audiences can watch whatever they like on streaming services.
And now, if you’re an actor hoping to get work in an exploding labour pool where there isn’t nearly enough work for you and your drama school peers, you’re not just competing against them, you’re competing against every actor a camera was ever pointed at because AI will be able to replicate and direct them near-effortlessly.
Then, as actress and director Justine Bateman (yes, her of Family Ties fame) told the media, when making yourself available for your likeness to be fed into AI to make whole new characters or content is standard practice in the industry, refusing to do so will only lock you out of work more decisively.
"[Actors will] have to do their homework first and really be able to spell out how those scans will be used, instead of it being a hand wavy, ‘Oh, just for second unit stuff’.
And if you ask me, that right there is one of the pivots upon which this whole matter rests. Just read the part of the agreement they finally made that relates to it (attributable once more to Deadline);
‘No consent is required to perform post-production alterations, editing, arranging, rearranging, revising or manipulating of photography and/or sound track for purposes of cosmetics, wardrobe, noise reduction, timing or speed, continuity, pitch or tone, clarity, addition of visual/sound effects or filters, standards and practices, ratings, an adjustment in dialogue or narration or other similar purposes or under any circumstance when dubbing or use of a double is permitted…’
So while clauses in contracts that read ‘your likeness will be replicated using AI’ means a studio or production company will have to pay the artist fairly according to the agreement that ended the strike, can you see all the grey area they’ll be desperately scrambling to reach to get themselves off the hook as clearly as I can?
I can see the defendant positions against the inevitable lawsuits already, the studio or producer’s lawyers spluttering in court; ‘but, but, but it was all post-production alterations, editing, arranging, rearranging, revising or manipulating!!’?
in fact, you don’t even have to wait. The writer of the 1989 Patrick Swayze thriller Road House has already sued MGM/Amazon over their wildly popular remake starring Jake Gyllenhaal, alleging they used AI to replicate the voices of some of the performers while they were on strike.
But here’s another, even scarier angle; this might be the first step in the studios bypassing the guilds and their agreements altogether.
Think they won’t? History is littered with industrial and political leaders opting for the nuclear option on previously unshakable incumbents if it will save money in the long run.
Thatcher starved the UK coal mining industry out. Murdoch broke the back of the Fleet Street print unions by building his own non-union infrastructure. Reagan fired the entire US air traffic control workforce.
Can’t you imagine Zaslav, Sarandos and Iger quietly amassing an army of non union directors, writers and VFX providers desperate enough to break into Hollywood, burning the system to the ground in order to rebuild it according to their own interests?
Sure it’s an industry where public perception matters (and there’s no worse perception about multimillionaire CEOs than if the public thinks they’re screwing workers), but nobody lives forever.
Zaslav has presided over a pretty terrible tenure at Warner Bros, culminating in a huge stock drop just a few months back. Maybe he’ll make it his last redemptive act before jumping ship with a golden handshake. Iger’s already getting the seat warm for his successor so he might care even less than Zaslav.
As one entertainment lawyer said; "I’m bracing for when studios make a film and bypass the guilds using AI, which I think is going to happen… Guild agreements are there regarding the treatment, conditions and payment for employees. Well, if you don’t use employees and you just bypass them completely, guilds can’t do anything about it."
But here’s yet another (perhaps peripheral) idea; the studios don’t really care about AI yet, they just needed everything to stop for long enough to reset their strategies. Except for Barbenheimer-level outliers there still aren’t enough people going back to cinemas because viewing habits changed forever while we were all in lockdown.
The studios thought that would translate to rivers of streaming subscriber gold, but they opted for quantity over quality, we as viewers weren’t amused, and investors are still punishing them for not getting it right.
What better way to spend six months getting their shit together without having to make anything than writers and actors going on strike (as this story) suggests?
But it’s not over yet. Even though actors, writers and studios are ostensibly happy with their film and TV deals, they’re still negotiating for videogame work.
Then it was industry musicians’ turn. It wasn’t as high profile a negotiation and they reached an agreement pretty quick, but I wanted to show you a picture of the dude in charge of their union because I thought it was a publicity still of a mafia don in a forthcoming project. Maybe when the AMPTP made their offer he told them to fuggedaboutit…
On screens now, sometimes franchises can surprise you. We saw it with the Predator films and the ace little action thriller Prey, and it’s the same thing with Evil Dead. If there was ever a reboot Hollywood was certain to screw up it was Sam Raimi’s 1981 camp classic, but Fede Alvarez’s 2013 remake was great, and Evil Dead Rise takes it up another notch.
I also can’t recommend survival thriller Fall enough. The simplest of stories, it’s about two young women trapped at the top of a 2,000 TV tower and it gets the balance between scares and character right, it’s the perfect length, it’s never less than credible and it’ll have you shredding the armrest with your nails.
And if you’re a fan of movies (who isn’t) you must be a fan of Steven Spielberg (who isn’t), and Spielberg, HBO’s 2017 documentary on his life and work will give you a new appreciation not just for the guy but moviemaking in general. It’s an interesting companion piece to The Fabelmans, which I also watched recently.