This time, I’m talking about the problem of trailers. The criticisms people have about trailers are so pervasive they’re cliches by now, like how the trailer contains all the best parts of a movie or how they give too much away. In fact, sometimes even filmmakers agree.
If you watch a lot of movies you unconsciously internalise a lot of the most common plotlines by osmosis, and the result is plenty of trailers leave you with the sense that you don’t even need to watch the movie any more, so completely has it given you all the story beats you need to know.
That’s related to a longstanding point of view that there are really only seven distinct plotlines humans recognise in literature, and that any stories that deviate from them are structurally unsound and feel ‘wrong’ to us.
It was articulated in a 2004 book, but the ideas and theory the author was investigating go back much further, even to the time of Jung.
However, this Filmism.net Dispatch is concerned with how those stories are marketed to us as consumers. I’ve been noticing trailers for a few movies lately where there’s a single very strong hook that gives the story an unexpected character turn (even if they appear to adhere to the seven basic plots… or 5, 20 or 36 as various other theories have maintained).
Have a look at the trailer to M Night Shyamalan’s Trap and Mel Gibson’s Flight Risk.
In the former, a guy is taking his daughter to a concert and gradually learns that a sizeable police force has the place locked down and surrounded. The reason? They’ve tracked a serial killer to the concert and intend to tighten their grip on the venue until they have him.
In the latter, a friendly, talky light plane owner gets a gig transporting a US Marshall and a mob witness across the country to a court date.
Before we start, a quick spoiler warning, although it’s a bit disingenuous because both trailers blow the central twists in each movie, which is exactly the point I’m raising here.
In Trap, the hero and loving dad Josh Hartnett plays turns out to be the serial killer the cops are looking for. And in Flight Risk, the pilot (Marky Mark Wahlberg) turns out to be a mob hitman assigned to silence the witness he’s transporting for good.
As is completely obvious from each trailer, both movies turn into the ‘Overcoming the monster’ plot, one of those identified in the book mentioned above.
In the case of Trap, the hero has to overcome the encroaching threat of the police dragnet. The fact that he’s actually a bad guy (being a murderer and all) and his antagonist is actually the force for good is immaterial to the structure of the plot, so the only reason you’d want to see the movie is to see how/if he gets out of his jam.
Even then, the fact it’s a Hollywood movie and the bad guy seldom wins, especially if his antagonists are figures American entertainment beatifies to an almost fetishised degree like cops or soldiers, even makes you confident in the knowledge of how it’s going to end.
All of which only gives you only one real reason to see the movie; the various set pieces that deal with how he’s going to give the cops the slip, maybe with an anticipation of the expert (maybe just adequate) deployment of the filmmaking crafts to generate and maintain the tension he’ll be feeling.
In Flight Risk, the trailer renders the rest of the story even simpler. The US Marshall (Michelle Dockery) is trapped in very small plane with the man she’s there to protect and deliver and another man who wants to kill her charge and will undoubtedly kill her if he has to.
The rest of the movie therefore literally can’t be anything else apart from her battle with him, mayb with the assurance that (as the good guy) she’ll win.
So while the trailers give the whole story away in each case, they make interesting thought experiments for the eponymous marketing people who worked on them.
On one hand, they could show the big twists in the trailers and make them features of the marketing rather than surprises to be kept until you see the movie. That would make the surprises more effective for audiences, but what else would convince you to see the movie if they’re not in the trailers?
Maybe the idea of a devoted dad at a concert with his teenage daughter when he learns there’s a serial killer there might be a compelling enough idea for you to see the movie. I mean, the first thing many of us would say is ‘why not just leave?’, but it still could work.
On the other hand, revealing that the devoted dad we’re sympathsing with is actually himself the killer is a much more arresting idea and might bring more punters to theatres, but you’ve also blown the big surprise that might be central to the water cooler chats after the weekend.
And if you do, there’s nothing left to offer an audience apart from the mechanical details about how he gets away (or doesn’t).
The same goes for Flight Risk. Reveal in the trailer that Marky Mark is a contract killer and establish the fight Dockery’s character is going to go through to fulfil her mission and survive, or set up a routine light plane flight with a mouthy pilot and leave the audience wondering what’s going to go wrong and why.
They’re both interesting examples of how differently the marketing of movies can be handled in different circumstances.
Studio marketing people, just like filmmakers, have aesthetic choices to make about the stories they tell in what they’re selling, and you can imagine the slightly agonised late night debates over boardroom tables over which would tantalise audiences more; reveal the killer or don’t?
On screens lately… nothing at all has impressed me enough to crow about it in the last month or so.