Well, I did it again. In a recent Filmism.net Dispatch I lamented how either my memory is getting so bad or I’ve simply watching so many movies in my life that I finally reached a new milestone (nadir, depending on your viewpoint).
I realised I’d not only watched a movie I’d already seen, I’d already reviewed it for this very website. Worse still, even when I realised I’d already reviewed it, I still didn’t remember watching it the first time.
I recently sat down to watch The Last Exorcism, a found footage-style horror movie I put on my list because it was said to have sparked off the current trend of found footage horror.
I felt a vague sense of familiarity at a few points but chalked it up to how similar things are in this genre. But no, there it was, already reviewed and posted.
I may officially be losing my marbles.
In far less disturbing news, I was recently thinking about what I realised was irrefutable proof that movies are objectively art.
I know how silly that sounds. Of course they are, in at least in the abstract. But I’ll bet you’d find plenty of film fans (I’m one of them) who’d argue that some movies are so precisely machine tooled to move merchandise and plant a flag for a brand that they’re far less ‘art’ than others.
We’re not getting into that per se; the debate/assertion that Hollywood’s never been materially interested in art is very ingrained and much older than most of us in the world today.
But I’ve formulated a theory that proves all movies (no matter how predesigned they are as loss leaders for Lego sets and Happy Meals) are art because of how subjective and debatable the origins are about the creative elements they’re comprised of.
Let me explain with a parallel. Who invented the internet? You might say it was Tim Berners Lee, but he just invented hypertext. In fact you can argue he didn’t even do that but built on previous iterations of similar plans (the term was coined in 1965).
You might say it was Vint Cerf and Robert Kahn, but they only developed TCP/IP. You might say it was the US Army because it developed ARPANet, which gave us the bare bones of the system.
But even before that, the atomic age engineer Vannevar Bush, who headed the US government’s invention aims, wrote a 1945 article describing a system he called the ‘memex’ (short for ‘memory extender’), which would let users create chains of connections between the text of articles, books and their own notes electronically.
All of which means the answer to the question ‘who invented the internet’ is somewhere between multifaceted and nonsensical.
Berners-Lee, Cerf, Kahn and countless others built on technology or ideas that already existed. Bush may well have been inspired by something like note-taking in the margins of books, goes all the way back to monastic scribes in the dark ages.
Crucially, the answer also changes depending on your perspective, interests and whether you have a financial stake. An engineer might consider the internet was invented by whoever hooked data up to phone lines. Consumers might think it was Marc Andressen, who gave us the first mass market way to access it.
Now transpose that to a simple example from the history of cinema. Who invented the zombie? If you’re a fan of The Walking Dead or The Last of Us and you’re over 30, you probably assume it was George Romero.
Most cinephiles will correct you by saying all Romero did was apply social comment and the mythology of the hunger for human flesh by the undead to something that already existed.
So we go back further, to movies like White Zombie and I Walked With a Zombie, which referenced the earliest popular mythology about zombies on screen where they’re the bodies of the recently deceased, raised from the dead by voodoo magic to be unpaid labour on plantations across the Caribbean. Eating human flesh didn’t come into it, they were automatons awaiting (usually nefarious) instruction .
Many people consider White Zombie is the original zombie film, the one from which everything from Train to Busan to World War Z are descended.
But look even deeper. Did Curt Siodmak, Ardel Wray, Inez Wallace or Garnett Weston (the credited writers of the above 30s and 40s classics) borrow from even older movies for their scripts?
The obvious answer would be that they were referencing voodoo mythology, a collision of influences where African, Creole, Cajun and a melting pot of other races and cultures wove new tales at the various crossroads of 19th century trade and migration.
Motifs from those cultural archetypes come from the steam age version of pop culture, with voodoo having originated and spread everywhere from Africa and the old Spanish Empire to the US, South America and the Caribbean of today.
In fact the popular picture we in the modern West have of voodoo is cherry picked from dozens of folkloric belief systems and cult practices early novelists and screenwriters thought were cool.
Or were the writers of White Zombie and I Walked with a Zombie inspired by older movies or stories with strong zombie elements?
In The Cabinet of Dr Caligari, the titular villain keeps the fearsome Cesare in a box and sends him to commit murder via mind control, the very definition of a voodoo-risen zombie working on a Haitian plantation.
Even though he was the screen’s earliest and most iconic vampire, you could argue Count Orlock from Nosferatu is actually a zombie with his stiff walk and undead pallor. He was a corrupted corpse, not the slick seducer Hollywood would transform Dracula into in later years by casting Bela Lugosi a decade before he’d appear in White Zombie, already the victim of rigid typecasting.
How do we know Siodmak or Weston weren’t influenced by both those movies and movements or ideas from older cultures? You can’t talk about mindless humanoid automatons commanded at will without mentioning the Golem, a figure from Jewish mythology that was made out of mud or clay and created to carry out instructions, usually around protection of the community.
Then there’s the popular idea that Jesus Christ, whose resurrection from the dead was his most defining characteristic and in fact made him Judeo-Christian cultural mythology’s first zombie.
But it gets more complicated still. Romero made zombies so famous and influential the flesh-eating resurrected corpse is now a genre all its own own, a classic monster from the human imagination like the vampire, ghost or werewolf, but he never actually used the word ‘zombie’.
Whenever the monsters are referred to in either the script or on screen by characters or news reports, they use the word ‘ghoul’.
Romero later said he considered true zombies to be the slave labour of voodoo mythology, and that his creatures were influenced more by the remnants of humanity turned into subhuman brutes from Richard Matheson’s I Am Legend.
The etymology of the word ‘ghoul’ referring to a creature that eats human flesh in this context dates back to pre-Islamic Arabia, with scholars between 700-1200 CE mentioning them.
The classic Arabian fictional text One Thousand and One Nights (which dates back to the ninth century) makes reference to a shape shifting creature that lures travellers into the desert and eats them.
Then, centuries later, Edgar Allen Poe’s The Premature Burial and HP Lovecraft’s Pickman’s Model both include the undead who consume living flesh. So were Poe and Lovecraft, and Romero in turn, influenced by first millennium Arabic legends, passing by 19th century Caribbean voodoo altogether?
And who’s to say which of those dual tracks of literary evolution contains the most definitive interpretation of a zombie? Who’s the single, buck-stops-here originator of the absolute dictionary definition, Ibn al-Nadim or Robert Kirkman and Frank Darabont?
The answer, of course, is both ‘none of them’ as well as ‘all of them’. They’ve all borrowed elements from what’s come before.
Stuart Gordon gave us one of the coolest alt zombie stories when he adapted Lovecraft’s Re-animator, using the bits he found the most narratively exciting no different from Al-Qazwini (1203–1283 CE), author of Ajā’ib al-Makhlūqāt wa-Gharā’ib al-Mawjūdāt (Marvels of Creatures and Strange Things Existing).
And that right there, as I’ve endeavoured to argue above, is art. It informs, borrows, references, homages, remixes and reimagines everything artists and audiences has previously loved, feared, enjoyed or wanted to express since the first storytelling took place between proto-humans around the campfire after the excitement of the hunt.
All of which makes even 2008’s Zombie Strippers a legitimate work of art, in spirit if not execution…
Nothing’s absolutely blown me away on screens over the last month or so, but I did watch too classics of very different cinematic movements. One is the very model of a mid 20th Century Western, full of the elements (a dusty small town, the bristling threat of violence, John Wayne) that made the genre was it was in Howard Hawks’ Rio Bravo.
The other was the point at where one of our most confounding and singular directorial talents in David Lynch started, in his seemingly completely allegorical and visually nightmarish Eraserhead.