Today I want to talk about that most hallowed tool used in Hollywood in the service of big names, the press narrative. More specifically, the inchoate, impenetrable way it moves, like the computation taking place in the black box of an AI agent, giving us no real way to know how it operates.
Confused? I’ll give you two words. Kevin Spacey.
If you talk about Harvey Weinstein nowadays, you might as well be referencing Hitler, Ed Gein and Jeffrey Epstein all at once. He’s beyond redemption at this point, and most people expect the next time he’s going to be in the news in a major way will be when he departs this Earth, maybe at the hands of a shiv or a broken glass bottle.
After Weinstein, Spacey seemed second in line as the least redeemable personality the MeToo movement wrought. His crime was supposedly to put the moves on an underage boy (although a quagmire of abuse and assault accusations followed, most of which he was exonerated of).
It’s still reprehensible behaviour, and objectively criminal, but it’s not a patch on the endless string of coercive sexual harassment, abuse and assault Weinstein was convicted of.
But Spacey was still spoken of in enraged tones across the entertainment firmament, fired from his hallowed position of creative director at London’s Old Vic theatre, hurriedly replaced by Christopher Plummer in Ridley Scott’s Rockefeller kidnapping drama All the Money in the World, written out of the final season of House of Cards and if you can believe a recent claim, homeless.
Now, Spacey is being talked about in the press alongside the word ‘comeback’. I know I said before the changing vagaries of public opinion are unidentifiable, but in this case Spacey’s new acceptance has come from quite specific places.
Italian actor/director Franco Nero was the first to cast him in a movie since his 2017 ouster. The Italian film industry awarded him something called the Maximo Excellence Award. He was also interviewed about the industry abruptly discarding him on the at the Italian Global Series Festival (IGSF).
Read whatever you like into the fact that so far it’s Italians who are feting Spacey so much, but I wasn’t really talking about the tangible examples of people giving him awards and interviewing him about the allegations and (non-legal) judgement about him. I’m talking about the narrative.
Spacey is using the platform of this acclaim in Italy to change (or take hold of and further facilitate the change in) the narrative about him.
He’s going to appear contrite. He’s going to say he used the time away from the industry to grow and learn. He’s going to thank the few people brave enough to stand by him and be cautious but forgiving about those who cast him out. In fact he’s already said and done all those things.
The point I’m making is this; there’s a narrative about public figures like him. The narrative about Weinstein was absolute and so well known it became pop culture, something we’re all inherently aware of like we are about Stalin.
The reason this is a thing worth talking about is that, like other movies, there are other narratives that never catch on.
When I mention the names Bob Weinstein (Harvey’s brother and The Weinstein Company co-founder, who completely disavowed him when MeToo broke), Morgan Freeman, Dustin Hoffman, Jeremy Piven, Aziz Ansari, Sylvester Stallone, Scott Baio, Richard Dreyfuss, Michael Douglas, James Woods, Anthony Andersen or Bill Murray, does anyone remember how accusations of offences ranging from inappropriate behaviour to sexual assault were levelled at them all?
Andersen was accused of rape by a film extra, sued for sexually suggestive remarks and rape by another and investigated about the alleged crimes by the LAPD.
Murray has a long string of misconduct accusations behind him, and his behaviour on a movie called Being Mortal (where a female crew member complained about him, resulting in a $100,000 settlement payment) saw the movie shut down entirely.
But many of those above have continued to work with few if any ramifications to their careers. They all (naturally) denied or downplayed their bad behaviour and many of them were accused of much worse than Spacey was, even before he was acquitted.
So why was he the second biggest villain of the whole shebang and not any of them? In the parlance of the media industry, there was no ‘sustained media traction’.
Because when I talk about about the press narrative being such a nebulous, uncontrolled thing, I don’t mean to imply it happens (or doesn’t) by accident.
You can bet that for every tweet or trade article about a whisper of scandal, publicists work the phones until late in the night to try and control the narrative about their clients.
They succeed or fail according to a host of factors like whether the reporter/publication and publicist has an outstanding favour owed, whether leverage (access to a bigger star in exchange for spiking a story) can be imposed, whether they’re in danger of being embarrassingly scooped or whether the time bomb is going to be too big to ignore and everybody’s going to be talking about it (a la Weinstein).
Don’t forget, Weinstein had such influence over and connectivity with every thread of the movie trade press, the stories that broke his behaviour wide open didn’t even come from Hollywood but MSN and The New York Times, even though it was supposed to be one of the worst-kept secrets in Hollywood.
Sometimes the above tactics work, sometimes they don’t, but those checks and balances (honest, fair or corrupt as they are) in the entertainment press produce a very different result depending on how the dominoes that comprise them fall.
There’s some alignment in the press narrative about the extent to which scumbags using power imbalances to prey on others and the crimes they’re accused of, but there are far more elements at play.
Now, exposing themselves to female costars or crew (Richard Dreyfuss, Louis CK), making suggestive comments (newsreader Tom Brokaw, Jeremy Piven) or worse isn’t the least bit defensible, but Roman Polanski and Woody Allen are still working and beloved by cineastes and festivals (albeit in Europe nowadays, where they’re less politically reactive) even though one drugged and anally raped a 13 year old girl and the other has been accused of sexual molestation of his own daughter.
The tide has of course gradually turned against both. Polanski was kicked out of the Academy, and there’s a lot of suspicion about Allen and support for his accusers, with several big names expressing regret about working with them both.
But contrast that with Spacey, who was initially accused of making an unwanted advance to a teenage boy.
Again, that’s not the least bit okay, but we still might ask; why is there no rhyme or reason about who gets banged up in the court of public opinion and thrown into director or actor jail and who dodges the worst slings and arrows of the MeToo era?
Simple. The press narrative.
On screens lately, I’m happy to say I can wholeheartedly recommend three incredibly good films (feels like forever since there have been that many around).
First is a 20 year old movie by screenwriter Kevin Wilmott (who writes and directs) called C.S.A.: The Confederate States of America. It’s an alternate history mockumentary set in the present day where the Southern Confederate states actually won the US Civil War and where slavery is as accepted, wide-ranging and at times high tech an industry in contemporary America as consumer product development or life insurance.
Next is a Canadian coming of age supernatural comedy romance (yes, it’s a genre all its own) called My Old Ass, where a young woman meets her older self.
In far lesser hands it could have been hackneyed and contrite, but the script, the characters, the performances and the directorial approach lift the conceit into the stratosphere. It’s been a long time since a movie made me mist up.
Lastly is Gareth (The Raid) Evans’ Havoc, a frenetic, grimy, violent, whiplash-inducing action flick that will remind you of how much fun the genre used to be.