Review

Eddington

Year: 2025
Production Co: A24
Director: Ari Aster
Writer: Ari Aster
Cast: Joaquin Phoenix, Pedro Pascal, Emma Stone, Clifton Collins Jr, Austin Butler

This movie finally made me a non-fan of Ari Aster. I was mildly impressed with Midsommar, liked Hereditary for the horror, failed spectacularly to connect with Beau is Afraid and grew very tired of this meandering, pointless melange somewhere in the butt-numbing running time.

It actually had the same problems as Beau is Afraid. It had a very distinctive set-up that had all the makings of a cohesive story – the dislike between the sheriff and mayor of a small New Mexican desert town in the midst of COVID lockdowns.

In fact that’s more of a set-up for comedic and dramatic hijinks than Beau is Afraid even had. But like that film, it soon abandons any semblance of narrative sense that’s obvious to see and what felt like the entire last hour was a mess of images and ideas, each more way out and extreme than the last.

Joaquin Phoenix is Joe Cross, the no-nonsense, conservative sheriff of the titular town, and he hates existing mayor and bar owner Ted (Pedro Pascal) so much he decides to run for office himself to unseat him.

He’s also dealing with a wife (Emma Stone) he loves dearly but who appears to be suffering from crippling depression, a mother in law who lives in their house because of lockdowns, lords it over the household and drives him crazy with the anti-vax and anti-government conspiracy theories she listens to.

There’s also a powderkeg of conflicting politics going on which will explode upon the news of the death of George Floyd, and suddenly Joe has to deal with angry Black Lives Matter protests on top of everything else.

Around the periphery there’s also a new age guru (Austin Butler) getting altogether too close to his wife for Joe’s comfort, a suspicion his own officers might be responsible for some of the antisocial activities in town, Antifa terrorists infiltrating Eddington in what will make for an explosive but nonsensical climax, the forthcoming construction of a gigantic data centre out in the desert and the political jostling it’s causing, the town’s kids and how mobilised they become in the face of the corrupt abuse of power and a hundred other weird subplots that feel like they spiral out of control.

I ended up with no idea what I was supposed to concentrate on or how it was all supposed to hang together. What didn’t help was a main character was way too thinly sketched, giving you nothing to hang onto. Is Joe a redneck dolt who buys into ill-advised political populism, a wily operator trying to bring his town under control before he loses it forever, or even a double murderer? All of the above (the third in a shocking and inexplicable turn of events.

That it starts with two guys in a small town swapping barbs across the mandated social distancing gap and ends with the town sheriff walking down empty streets at night emptying a middy gun into the darkness at hidden enemies says something about how off the rails it all goes.

It effectively portrays the way we lived at the time – all online and with only podcasts and social media to connect us, with too many conflicting voices trying to recruit us to their side of a rapidly splintering body politic. It just doesn’t know what to do with it.

Although on second thought, Aster is too good a filmmaker to wing it and he obviously knew exactly what he was doing, he just didn’t want any of the rest of us in on it.